Cutting Through the Creative Noise: Why More Ads Isn’t Better Advertising

Cutting Through the Creative Noise: Why More Ads Isn’t Better Advertising image
By Nicole Lumley 18 November 2026

AI has made ad creative cheap to produce. Teams can now generate, test and iterate at a pace that would have been unthinkable a few years ago. But when everyone can make more, more stops being an advantage. The edge in mobile games marketing is shifting away from output and back towards ideas, judgment and craft.

That was the thread running through a Gamesforum San Francisco panel moderated by Kristina Taylor, UA at EA, with Tina Shaw, Creative Director at Activision Blizzard Media; Summer Liu, CMO at SocialPeta; Erkay Uzun, Co-founder of Unico Studio; and Tomas Jenneborg, CEO of Reactional Music. Asked for one word to sum up the state of mobile game creative today, they chose copying, cluttered, creative inflation and noisy.

Volume is no longer a moat

The scale of output is staggering. SocialPeta has tracked more than 2 billion ads across over 50 networks, and in the first half of this year, top AI app advertisers were running 1,000 to 1,500 ads a month. Games advertisers averaged around 800.

When every team can reach those numbers, sheer quantity loses its power to differentiate. "Your capability of producing more ads may not work any more," said Summer.

The industry has become very good at one thing and not necessarily the other. "We are getting really better at producing ads," said Erkay, "but not necessarily better at advertising."

A variation is not an idea

The problem isn't iteration itself. Building on a winner is still the smartest low-risk move a team can make, and AI makes it easier than ever. The problem is mistaking iteration for creativity.

"Running hundreds of variations of an idea is very different from having hundreds of different ideas," Erkay said. "If all your teams focus on creating more variations, you will miss the most important thing: the next winning creative."

The answer is to run optimisation and exploration as parallel tracks, with deliberate investment in both. Summer said most UA teams she works with follow an 80/20 split, with 80% of budget scaling winners and 20% going to genuinely new concepts, defined as new ideas rather than colour or element swaps.

Tina builds that discipline into her team's output. Each month they produce 15 new pieces and 15 iterations, and at least three of the new pieces must be something they've never done before. "UA is the place you have to take risks," she said. "If it doesn't work, you're still going to get data. You're still going to learn why."

Data should inform creative, not dictate it

More data was supposed to make creative decisions easier. In practice, it has made it tempting to chase what already works, which is how an entire category ends up looking the same.

Tina draws a clear line between creative that is data-driven and creative that is data-informed. "The consumer is savvy enough now," she said. "If we're creating content that's copying something else, they can lose interest and be put off by it."

Summer, whose business is ad intelligence, made the case for data as a tool rather than a compass. It helps teams kill bad ideas faster and spot white space, but it rarely produces a surprise. "Data helps you pick the battlefield," she said. "Your judgment picks the weapons."

Tomas went further, urging teams to look less at what competitors are running. "Be brave. Try it, and don't look too much at others."

The best creative is built on the game itself

When teams do find something that lasts, it tends to be rooted in the real experience of the game rather than in a formula.

Tina's "Chillin' With Call of Duty Mobile," set on the player-favourite Hijacked map with a sniper loadout, has stayed in the top two for 28 months, with $1.7 million in spend and a 25.2% [CHECK: metric – transcript unclear] and no iterations. Its staying power has since spawned a whole family of variants. "It's gameplay first," she said.

SocialPeta's data points the same way. The structures that keep working are simple: a two-to-three-second hook, real gameplay at the core and a clear payoff. And as audiences grow used to AI-generated elements, real people and live action are gaining ground, including micro-drama-style openings that cut quickly to gameplay.

The hook still matters. Tina just thinks about it differently. "I call it a face punch," she said. "You face punch them, and then you give them something that's beautiful."

The cheapest install isn't the best one

If the industry is going to judge creative on quality, it needs to measure quality. CTR, IPM and CPI remain useful early signals, but they reward the click, not the player.

In the hypercasual era, players from different creatives tended to have similar lifetime values, so a low CPI was enough. That's no longer true. With networks running AI-driven ROAS and retention campaigns, the creative now shapes who arrives. "We're easily seeing 2x, 3x value coming from one creative compared to another," said Erkay. Judging creative properly means waiting long enough to see retention and long-term ROAS.

Tina added a reminder that not every signal comes from a dashboard. Social listening, including reading the comments on live ads, shows in real time whether players are engaging or uninstalling. "It's like a marriage," she said. "You've got your social listening and you've got your data, and you're seeing where they cross over."

Sound is an underused differentiator

In a feed full of lookalike visuals, audio is one of the few levers most teams haven't fully pulled.

For Tomas, the barrier has been access, not interest, with licensing hit music long tangled in legal and commercial terms. When it is used, it has to land instantly. "If the recognisable hook comes after eight to ten seconds, you may lose your investment," he said.

Tina pointed to a mainline Call of Duty ad set to Debussy's Clair de Lune as proof of how far the right track can carry a piece. She is also exploring 3D audio and rhythms built entirely from game sound effects.

What doesn't work is asking for attention. Erkay's team tested prompts telling players to turn sound on across several games and removed them. "It works much better if you just have it there."

Players are not a bank

The panel's closing point was the most fundamental. Chasing volume, copying winners and optimising purely for short-term returns all come from the same place: treating players as a source of revenue rather than an audience to win over.

"We need to unlearn that our players are a bank," said Tina. "We can't constantly be asking for withdrawals. If we get them hooked on loving the game, the transactions within it are typically very organic."

Erkay summed up where that leaves the industry. "Maybe we're going full circle, back to quality over quantity."

In a market flooded with near-identical ads, the advantage now lies less in how much you make, and more in having something worth making.

antage now lies less in how much you make, and more in having something worth making.

SIGN UP TO OUR NEWSLETTER

You’ll receive our leading content, news and info about upcoming webinars, podcasts and of course discounts to our live Gamesforum events

Sign up now